ANZAC. Gelibolu Peninsular, Turkey. Wednesday 19th & Thursday 20th September 2018.
Sacred Cows and Foreign Fields.
A personal journey through the myths and facts of ANZAC
Baggage.
Child
I was born thirteen years after the end of World War Two (WWII). Thirty- three years after the Gallipoli campaign. Two years after the Korean war. By the time I was aware enough of Anzac Day to remember it now I was living in a small (population 1010) town near the geographical centre of NSW.I have no service people in my family. My maternal grandfather was too old for WWI, my paternal grandfather too young. My father and mother too young for WWII. No uncles or great uncles saw active service. The closest any relative got was "Nasho". National Service*. I had no relative to regale, or caution, me with war stories. My parents were not nationalistic and there was no 'war culture' taught or modeled at home.
War was part of my non-formal education. Comics, television sit-coms, serials and movies, and play. I was born to the 'winning' side and was exposed, only, to that version of history. The media source was almost exclusively the USA and it focused on WWII. The Japanese (the Japs) and the Germans (the Nazis) were cast as the enemy and the good guys were US troops, with a smattering of English forces. I remember once, in one comic, Australian troops played a part in the action, in the US success. Russians, French (any European country), Canadians, Egyptians and any other country that fought alongside Allies or Enemy barely rated a mention. The message that came through to a young boy was US and them.
Like all losers the armies were demonized, especially the Japanese. Germans were portrayed as efficient and disciplined, from blindly obedient and process-driven through to cruel and mulishly blinkered. The Japanese were a level beyond the Germans. More than cruel, the Japanese forces were portrayed as sadistic, unthinkingly devoted to Emperor and empire, inhumanely creative. Innumerable sheep with rifles, bayonets, a suicidal obedience and a demented gleam in their non-Caucasian eyes.
As boys, running around the neighbourhood backyards, we were fighting Nazis and Japs with our toy rifles and "A-a-a-a-a!" machine gun sound effects. We were far more likely to play "cowboys-and-Indians" than Anzac and Turks.
I remember learning that Anzacs were incredibly brave and battled terrible odds and conditions, lots of them died and they were all heroes.
My earliest memories of Anzac Day are associated with the school band. An enthusiastic and dynamic school principal had arrived in town to manage the 300 kids and staff. He initiated many improvements to the school. He procured donations of grass runners and eventually, using student labour, planted out the entire dirt-and-prickle school grounds in lawn. He scrounged up some old and unused brass instruments from a nearby town, found a local PMG (Telco) technician who could play trumpet and set about creating a school marching band.
I was still in primary school and loved learning brass, despite having to attend the school and practice on Saturday mornings! Euphonium, flugel horn, trumpet and cornet, I had a go at all of them! At some point we had actually learned enough tunes to lead a parade. Our first public outing would be to lead the annual Anzac Day march.
There were many Scots descendents in the rural aristocracy of the area and it was decided to hire proper Scottish uniforms for the band at its first performance. Spats, hose, kilts, sporrans, sashes (over our white shirts), and tartan hats were ordered. One big burly Senior boy, who had never been to band practice and couldn't play a note, got to be the marching band leader and carry a mace and wear a tall black bearskin hat and tell us when to play and when to stop.
The hire gear arrived a week before the march and that was when I and the few other 'youngsters' in the band were told no tartan finery had been hired for us. No kilts, sporrans or sash. White spats were all that we got. So the call went out to parents of daughters at the school to lend their tartan skirts. I was not the only boy-child to knowingly wear female clothing in public that day. I don't know how the others felt because it was never discussed, ever. What I recall feeling most keenly, to add insult to injury, was the ignominy of wearing the tartan 'dress' of one of the most unattractive girls in the school. [I met her years later at a school reunion and this was no longer true.]
The band was a stunning success. We led the way from the RSL hall (the biggest building in town), down the main street, U-turn at the post office and an hundred metres later left turn into the town's only park and the needle shaped stone cenotaugh. We led the Diggers and ex-services people (a good few who had seen service in WWI), the entire school, the religious private school, the service club representatives, the churches, everyone. The band teacher played the Last Post and Reveille. Wreaths were laid, speeches made. Then we struck up again and led them all back to the RSL hall, where the entire show disbanded, out there on the street.
The ex-soldiers, partners and other 'dignatories' would all be fed lunch at long rows of trestle tables covered in white butcher's paper and flowers. We band kids were allowed inside the hall for a soft drink. A free soft drink, inside the hall. It was foreign territory for me. There was many a gnarled hand wanting to shake ours, or gripping our skinny shoulders saying, "Good onya cobber!"
I had no idea, as a child, of what happened inside the RSL hall after we left.
The brass band had made all the difference, bringing pomp to the already fifty year old ceremony. Turning a shambled cow walk into a "real" and "proper" parade. For me it was about dead people, how they were brave and wouldn't be forgotten; and the unspoken shame of wearing a dress.
In 1971 and '72 i moved away from my family and lived and schooled in Sydney. I attended a public high school that boasted more students than my home town's population. I walked to school via a path that led past the great expanse of brickwork supporting the rear of the science labs. I remember walking in alone one morning and in the bright sunshine and crisp newness of the day read the writing on the wall. "FUCK THE WAR!" it said, in black letters two metres high. I was gobsmacked, bewildered. Why would someone do this? Why would they bother? Out loud, incredulous, I said to myself, "But the war's been over for twenty- five years!"
It was 1971, it was not WWII being protested, but Vietnam!
I was raised in a fundamentalist Christian family, where bellicosity went about as far as hearty renditions of "Onward Christian Soldiers". Politics was not discussed. Social degeneration (bikinis, sport on Sunday, kids selling raffle tickets) was minimized. It was up to my best mate to set me straight on which war. I felt foolish, I had heard about the fighting over there.
I moved back to the town of 1010 people but didn't rejoin the band. We moved the next year and Anzac day became negotiable in our family, so I didn't go. There was always a ceremony at school, Anzac Assembly. The poem, the speeches. Asking selfish teenagers to remember that others had paid with their lives for my privileges: TV, LPs, jeans, rock n roll; that's how i saw it, it never quite connected.
In Senior high school I read a play that further enlightened me on Anzac day. The One Day of the Year was written by Alan Seymour in 1958 and first performed in 1960. In the play an adult son challenges his ex-service father's motives and actions on Anzac day, and in so doing the play challenged the' sacred cow' of Australian celebrations. It changed my perceptions of Anzac Day by the naming of many small impressions I had not processed. Pinching from Wiki, "... the background of the beery haze.. the heady nostalgic sentimentality of Anzac Day... the nobody who becomes a somebody on this day of days."
It seemed to me that it was no longer about heroes, it was about getting on the piss. It wasn't bravery in the face of terrible odds, it was having a spin at two-up. To 17 year old me it appeared to be about "how good are we?" Where was the horror at the horror of war? If war is such a terrible thing and we must not forget, why do we keep on doing it? How can you party at a funeral? (I'm English/Scots, not Irish😏)
The One Day of the Year crystallized for me what Anzac Day had become: a piss-up!
Vietnam was well and truly lost and over by the time I finished high school. It would be another 25 years before I would attend another Anzac Day service.
In that time Australia and her defence personnel would be involved in peacekeeping missions in Namibia (89), Cambodia (92-93), Somalia (93), Rwanda (94-95), Bougainville (94 and from 97), East Timor (Timor Leste) (99-00, 06-13), Solomon Islands (03-17) and Afghanistan (06-13). Australia contributed to the 1991 Gulf War and the invasion of Iraq (03). I can remember the protests, and protesting, over the Gulf war and invasion of Iraq. I can remember not quite believing it was all about oil. I can remember feeling a bit proud of Australia's peacekeeping missions in Timor Leste, the Solomon's and, to a lesser extent, Afghanistan.
Adult
The new century brought me and my new family back to a small community. 2500 this time, not 1010! It was half an hour from a much larger garrison town, with army and air force bases. Working, socialising, spending time in these new towns brought contact with services and ex-services people and their families. Contact brought me to understand that defence forces are personal as well as political. It's made up of individuals who, while holding different values to me, love and learn and grow and struggle and succeed. Who are real. What the individuals do, under orders from my government, while they do it well, is often unhelpful, inappropriate and wrong. Peacekeeping? Yes! Following the globalised neo-con corporate wing of the USA? No!I was led back to this particular day of the year by my children. In this small place I now called home the Anzac Day commemoration was always a service held at dawn. Held in a park above the water of a picture postcard perfect bay. The school children marched behind the veterans and others. From the small RSL hall it was only five hundred metres up a slight hill to the park above the bay, there to join the dark pre-dawn gathering. Slowly, with the earth's motion, there was a revelation of details in the gloaming. A monochrome feel. The crowd, eerily quiet for so many people. Familiar faces in unfamiliar uniforms. Adding to the dissonance, locals, only ever seen during the day clad in shorts and t- shirts, now dressed warmly against the chill.
The tone of the service had changed in 25 years. Gone was the 'guts and glory' reverence for youth's blood boldly spilt for the sake of a color TV. Now it was tempered by loss. As though the fourteen year old nation, Australia, who had waded onto the beach at 'Gallipoli' had fought too many fights for too little; lost so much more than was ever gained. As a forty year old it had felt like defending the family home; but at 55, and again at 64, let alone at 89 and 102 it felt like a duty, an obligation, maybe a big rip-off.
Over my children's primary school years of Anzac Day services I learned to walk away when the "address" was given. Depending on who delivered it, and there was a mixture of types and positions, I would feel overwhelmingly sad or overwhelmingly angry.
For the loss of each individual spark.
I understand the importance of recognising the loss, and acknowledging the sacrifice. Of remembering it is an obscene waste of everything good, sacred and sustainable. I'd like to hear the cry, "Never again. No more!" [Once. Once I heard this. A visiting ex-services presenter, down by the bay.] And I thank from the depths of my heart every man and woman who went.
Sharing friendships with the Vietnam Vets who ran the local RSL, who are not so many years older than me, gave me further insight into this one day of the year. It wasn't just a piss-up for them, some didn't even bother the Spinner. My callow lack of psychological understanding had previously made no allowance for people who had faced death and demons, bloodshed and blood shed, so many kinds of loss, and the flagrant pointlessness of war. In most cases it was having that one day every year to be once again in the company of people who had held YOUR life in their hands. Who had come through, landed the both of you, alive and peaking on adrenaline and mortality, safe on the other side. Who could, for all your steely emotional distance 364 days of the year, reflect your tears in their own, as eyes well up at the intoning of a name. That mate, all those mates, that never made it home. Someone who understood.
It was harder for the Vietnam Vets. They came home to the unusual phenomena of cultural shame for that war. Australian lapdogs biting at the call of the US whistle. The politicians, this country, were the lapdogs, spilling blood for someone else's greed and glory. The personnel didn't deserve to be shunned. They had been as brave, as determined, as scared, as traumatised, as successful as any other combatant at any other time.
So it was all this I carried with me to the Gallipoli Peninsula in 2018.
View from a Bicycle
I am travelling by bicycle. Solo. No agenda, simply pleasing myself. Following whims and whimsy. I have crossed into Turkey from Bulgaria and ridden south. I am exploring the Anzac sites because I am in Turkey. I am not in Turkey because of Anzac. It occurs to me that, at least for Australians, it is the first site in Europe that has an Australian story tied to it. Our first part on the world stage, playing with the big guns. It feels 'right' to visit. I can and I do.
The first dissonant fact I discover is that the locals call it Gelibolu, not Gallipoli. The whole peninsular is named after this small town, around 30,000 now, which is at the north-eastern end of the Dardenelles. In terms of actual fighting in WWI Gelibolu was far from the action. Gelibolu is 70km and 50km from the two sites Allied forces landed in April 1915.
![]() |
| Looking back on Gelibolu. |
So Gallipoli is not the name of a beach, or bay, or mountain, or district that Allied forces captured and died for.
Gallipoli, I understand now, is the anglicise-ation of the local name for the peninsula. It feels awry though. How did I get that misunderstanding? I expected to go to a place called Gallipoli, to stand AT Gallipoli; not to be able to spend a week riding a bicycle from one end to the other!
[The following war details all come from information plaques and displays at the various sites and memorials, unless otherwise indicated.]
The 1915 Allied campaign had four parts to it:
Thirdly, a second land invasion starting on 6th August with British forces landing at Suvla Bay, and Anzacs attacking ridges north of Anzac Cove.
Finally, the evacuation of troops: a) from Suvla and Anzac on the night of 19/20th December; and, b) from Helles on 8/9th January, 1916.
The Naval Campaign.
The Dardenelles is a thin strait that separates the Aegean Sea, in the north-east Mediterranean, from the broader Sea of Mamara. From the Sea of Mamara ships can navigate through the Bosphorous Strait, which ancient and modern Istanbul straddles, to the Black Sea. On the north side of the Dardenelles is the Gelibolu Peninsular.The Allies expected little resistance. The initial expectation was that the fleet, essentially Britain and France, would steam up the Dardenelles, blasting the shore defences to smithereens, into the Sea of Mamara. There the fleet was expected to obliterate the Ottoman** navy and move on to the Bosphorous. The Ottomans, by this time, would have read the 'writing on the wall', surrendered, and allowed the Allies an ice-free supply line to Russia, via the Black Sea. Russia, with Allied supplies, would be reinforced in their attack on the Axis countries of Germany and Austria. The war on two fronts would fatally weaken the Axis' defence on the bogged down Western Front. Simple! Winston Churchill, Minister for the Navy, said, " A good army of 50,000 men and sea power - that is the end of the Turkish menace. "
The 100 vessel fleet steamed into the Dardenelles on the 18th March. A large fleet of minesweepers cleared the way for the battleships and destroyers. The big ships with their big guns bombarded the shore defences.
The Ottoman were not caught unaware, they knew this day would come. They had previously observed the Allied minesweepers remove the mines laid down in the straits, and both sides continued to, respectively, lay mines and disable them.
There is a point, around Çanakkale (pronounced Chun-uck-a-lee, emphasis on uck) and Eceabat, where the straits narrow (The Narrows) and then kink in a dog-leg. To this day big ships have to manoeuvre slowly and carefully and tugs actively assist the big vessels navigate this section. One Turkish tactician arranged for a line of mines to be laid parallel to the shore, instead of the usual and expected perpendicular, where the big ships would be manoeuvring. This was missed by the minesweepers and had the effect of taking HMS Irresistible out of action.
This next story has become an enduring part of Turkish WWI history and lore. A defensive artillery emplacement at Medjidieh Fort, on the Peninsular side and at The Narrows, had been firing on the invading fleet with little effect when it was hit by a shell. All but two of the defenders were killed or taken out of action. One survivor, injured and made deaf by the blast, rose and looked out over the damaged rampart to see the HMS Ocean below. The other man still standing urged him to come away, fearful of another shell. The first man, Seyit Ali Çabuk, usually called Seyit Onbaşi (Corporal Seyit) now, or the "Hero of Çanakkale", refused to leave. Instead he urged his colleague to assist him in checking the gun. It was undamaged and still operational, but the crane that lifted the shells from the stockpile to the gun was wrecked. Old mate still wanted to bail, but Corporal Seyit pushed him aside and grabbed one of the shells for the 240/35mm gun and single-handedly carried it to the breech and loaded it. Carrying out each of the tasks usually fulfilled by a team of men, and a crane, Seyit loaded, aimed and fired the gun three times. His third shot struck HMS Ocean below the waterline and it subsequently capsized.
The Battle of Çanakkale resulted in the sinking of 1 French and 2 British battleships. 1 British and 2 French warships were "severely destroyed". The Allied fleet retreated, the home side had won that round. The storming of the straits was never attempted again.
In one of those curious afterwords on individual achievement Seyit, who was promoted to corporal and publicised as a hero, was photographed with one of the shells he had carried. Seyit couldn't budge it, let alone lift it! No small wonder because each shell weighed 275kg. His photo was taken with a wooden replica. Seyit is quoted as saying to the photographer and crew, "If war breaks out again, I'll lift it again."
Land invasion.
The victory at the Battle of Çanakkale only made it more likely that there would be an invasion with ground troops.The Allied command wanted free passage to the Black Sea. It was decided to initiate a land invasion to take out the Ottoman defences of the Dardenelles. The land invasion started on the 25th April at two sites: Anzac Cove by Australian and New Zealand forces; and Cape Helles by British and French.
The Ottoman army had set its defences on the Peninsular in anticipation of an invasion. Colonel Mustapha Kemal Bey, later known as Attaturk (Father of Turkey), and that's another story!*** was the commander of the 19th Division, acting under German commander Liman von Sanders. Kemal set up and commanded defences on the western end of the Peninsular and led the Ottoman defence against the Anzacs.
Cape Helles
Cape Helles is the very south-western tip of the Gelibolu Peninsular. The 'north head' of the Dardenelles. Troops managed to secure the first 5km of the tip before being held to that line by the defenders. They held this territory for eight months, never making it to the high country that was their initial goal.
Unlike the Anzacs, who landed at dawn, the British in the south were to land in full daylight on five beaches around Cape Helles. To make up for this loss of surprise, a heavy naval bombardment was to cover the British landing. This meant the Turks had a good idea of what was coming as the biggest amphibious landing of the war began.
The following is the story of one of those landings.
As part of the wider five-pronged British attack, the Lancashire Fusiliers were chosen to land on and take control of a small, sandy cove just 350m long and between 15m and 40m wide between Cape Helles and Tekke Burnu. It was so well defended that the Turks may have regarded it as impregnable to an attack from open boats. Nevertheless, the attack began at 6am on April 25.
Captain Richard Willis, who led C Company during the attack, was one of several survivors to record the events of the day: “Not a sign of life was to be seen on the peninsula in front of us. It might have been a deserted land we were nearing in our little boats. Then crack!… The signal for the massacre had been given; rapid fire, machine-guns and deadly accurate sniping opened from the cliffs above, and soon the casualties included the rest of the crew and many men.
“The timing of the ambush was perfect; we were completely exposed and helpless in our slow-moving boats, just target practice for the concealed Turks, and within a few minutes only half of the 30 men in my boat were left alive. We were now 100 yards from the shore, and I gave the order ‘overboard’. We scrambled out into some four feet of water and some of the boats with their cargo of dead and wounded floated away on the currents still under fire from the snipers. With this unpromising start the advance began. Many were hit in the sea, and no response was possible, for the enemy was in trenches well above our heads.
“We toiled through the water towards the sandy beach, but here another trap was awaiting us, for the Turks had cunningly concealed a trip wire just below the surface of the water and on the beach itself were a number of land mines, and a deep belt of rusty wire extended across the landing place. Machine-guns, hidden in caves at the end of the amphitheatre of cliffs, enfiladed this.
“Our wretched men were ordered to wait behind this wire for the wire-cutters to cut a pathway through. They were shot in helpless batches while they waited, and could not even use their rifles in retaliation since the sand and the sea had clogged their action. One Turkish sniper in particular took a heavy toll at very close range until I forced open the bolt of a rifle with the heel of my boot and closed his career with the first shot, but the heap of empty cartridges round him testified to the damage he had done. Safety lay in movement, and isolated parties scrambled through the wire to cover."
The Lancashire Fusiliers had started the day with 27 officers and 1,002 other men. Twenty-four hours later, a head count revealed just 16 officers and 304 men.◇
That was one of five!
Anzac
At dawn on 25th April the Anzacs began landing on either side of a headland known as Ari Burnu, or Ariburnu. The northern landing site is what is now known as Anzac Cove (Anzac Koyu). The aim of that first day was to capture the heights of the Sari Bair range and then continue inland to cut off reinforcements to Cape Helles and the Allied invasion there.
Despite terrible losses the Anzacs pushed the defenders back from the heights and a few separate groups of Anzacs actually saw the water of the Dardenelles. The defenders, however, were reinforced through the day and their resistance strengthened. They pushed back. By nightfall none of the Anzac objectives had been held. They did have 16,000 troops landed, but the beaches were full of wounded.
![]() |
| Blue: Anzac. Red: Ottoman. |
The commanders on the ground recommended a withdrawal, but they were ordered to stay. Sir Ian Hamilton issued the order to hold on: “You have got through the difficult business, now you dig, dig, dig, until you are safe.”♧
The Australian War Memorial website had this to say: "The landing on Gallipoli on 25 April 1915 did not go to plan. The first boats, carrying the covering force, became bunched and landed about a mile north of the designated beaches. The main force landed on too narrow a front and became intermixed, making it difficult for the troops to regroup. The troops had to scale treacherously steep ground with little understanding of the terrain. A few Australians almost reached their objectives for that first day but were forced back. This failure bogged the operation down for the rest of the campaign." ♧
The Turks tell of another facet to this story. Sub-Lieutenant Ibrahim Hayrettin was in charge of a squad of men that resisted the Anzac force at the size of battalion from a hill (later called Fisherman's Hut) as the Anzacs landed. They continued for three hours without reinforcement or communication, successfully preventing the Anzacs from advancing up that hill. Sub-Lieutenant Hayrettin became aware that Anzacs had occupied an adjacent hill and their further advance would cut his forces off. They withdrew to higher ground and, engaging the advancing Anzacs, slowed down their progress. However the Turkish troops ran out of ammunition. Losing hope, they retreated further at which time they came across Colonel Kemal (their commander).
"Why are you fleeing?" Kemal asked.
"Sir, the enemy..." replied the soldiers, pointing out the advancing Anzacs.
Kemal looked at the enemy advancing freely towards his own position and said, "No one runs away from the enemy."
This time they replied, "We have run out of ammunition, sir."
Hearing this Mustapha Kemal ordered them, "But you have your bayonets if you do not have ammunition. Fix bayonets, lie down."
Upon this order the soldiers fixed their bayonets and laid down on the ground. As the withdrawing Turkish soldiers laid down and took cover the Anzacs laid down and took cover too. Thus their advance to the height of Chunuk Bair was checked. Kemal later said, "That was the very moment we won!"
So the troops, as ordered, dug in. Both sides dug trenches, at many points separated by only short distances. The closest was 8m, but it averaged more like 12-15m apart. There's a photo of an Anzac trench with chicken wire extending metres above the ground. This was to prevent the hand grenades thrown by the Turks from landing inside the trench. Rows of trenches were dug, parallel to each other. And trenches were dug deep, deeper than the enemy's trench and (on occasion) under the enemy's trench, where explosives were detonated.
![]() |
| Red: Allies. Blue: Ottoman. Black: current road. |
The commanders, on both sides, would plan and order attacks on the enemy's trenches and many lives were lost and little ground made.
![]() |
| Original trench now almost full of dirt. |
Cape Helles May Attack.
On the 6th May an attack was planned for Cape Helles. A combined assault by British, Australian, New Zealand and French forces had little effect. On the 8th May the Anzacs were ordered forward. Moving north over open and exposed ground the troops found the enemy fire so accurate and so intense that some men raised their shovels in front of their faces to protect themselves. The Turkish lines were not reached and over 1000 Australians and 800 New Zealanders were killed or wounded.
Anzac May Attack
In the darkness of the early hours of the 19th May, in a planned offensive, Turkish soldiers advanced in waves on their enemy's trenches above Anzac Cove. The Turks were met with a concentrated fire that kept them from entering the Anzac trenches, except in two places. For about six hours the Turks pressed their attack only to be driven back.Over 10,000 Turkish soldiers were hit and an estimated 3,000 lay dead between the lines. In this battle the Anzacs lost 160 dead and 468 wounded. The Turkish bodies lay out in the open sun until a truce was negotiated for the 24th May to permit burial of the dead.
Stalemate
When the Gallipoli campaign started no Allied generals expected it to last so long or to cause so many casualties. The number of wounded from the initial invasion overwhelmed the poorly organised medical facilities. During major attacks many hours passed before a wounded man received adequate care.As the summer heat intensified, conditions deteriorated. Primitive sanitation led to a plague of flies and the outbreak of disease. Thousands of men were evacuated suffering from dysentery, diarrhoea and enteric fever. The diet was poor and monotonous: bully beef, hard biscuits, jam and tea. The men suffered particularly from lice in their clothing. Morale sank as the prospect of victory receded.
In an attempt to seize the initiative and break the deadlock the British planned another invasion. There would be a British landing at Suvla Bay and a major assault to the north of the Anzac position to capture the high ground leading to Chanuk Bair, as well as two supporting attacks on Lone Pine and the Nek.
August Offensive.
On the afternoon of 6th August at Lone Pine the Australians attacked and occupied Turkish frontline positions against determined Turkish counter-attacks. Most of this desperate fighting took place at close quarters in Turkish trenches.Suvla Bay
At 9:30pm on 6th May an armada of British ships approached Suvla Bay. From Royal Navy battleships, passenger liners, Thames tugs and paddle steamers 10,000 soldiers disembarked. There were three landing points, one in the bay and two to the south of Nibrunesi Point, the southern headland of Suvla Bay.By midnight two companies of troops from the south disembarkation advanced on Lala Baba, the high ground behind Nibrunesi Point. The action was brief and bloody and by the time they were in control of the hill they had lost all but two officers and at least a third of the men.
Inside the bay the three destroyers towing landing craft anchored about one kilometre south of their intended markers and in the wrong order. Landing craft foundered in the shallow water several times, forcing the men to wade to shore in neck deep water. Once on dry land, in the darkness and facing unknown terrain, the soldiers (untested and with no battle experience) found themselves disoriented. One battalion quickly moved inland and engaged Ottoman forces on the ridge to the east. Another unit failed to locate its target, a hill just to the north of the salt lake behind Suvla Bay. Many other units found themselves scattered, with their commanders unsure of their location or their orders!
When the sun rose over Suvla on 7th August only the horns of the bay and Lala Baba were in British hands. Ottoman forces regrouped inland and reinforcements were approaching from the east. It was not until 9th that the Brits mounted an assault on the first night's objectives. The defending Ottoman troops were prepared and successfully repelled them.
The Nek and Chunuk Bair
On the morning of 7th August the attack on the Nek was initiated. Four waves of Australians were cut down before they reached enemy lines.The main attack of the August offensive was made by a mixed New Zealand, Australian, British and Indian force against the heights of Chunuk Bair and nearby peaks. Between the 7-9th August troops made their way up the steep slopes and through the deep gullies on the approaches to the heights. Some units became lost in this wild country and planned assaults were often carried out too late and with inadequate support. In the official history, Charles Bean wrote of the rough country of the Gallipoli peninsula. He described confusing slopes, perpendicular crags, and gorse-like scrub. "The growth was stubborn, and, in the steep gravelly waterways with which the hillside was scored, it was as much as a strong man could do to fight his way through it, to say nothing of carrying his heavy kit and rifle." ♧ [let alone engage defenders and dodge bullets!]
The New Zealanders, fighting desperately and sustaining great losses, reached the Chunuk Bair summit and could see the Dardenelles. By 10th August the Kiwis had been replaced by British troops when the Turks determinedly counter-attacked and regained the summit.
The Suvla attack was required because the first two invasions had become deadlocked. Suvla repeated this result. All three fronts bogged down in trench warfare. No one gaining and holding further ground: stalemate.
Withdrawal
After August no further major attacks were mounted. The British government grew alarmed at the failure to break through to the Dardenelles and there was mounting criticism of the whole venture. In November, when winter arrived, there were men who froze to death at their posts and over 16,000 troops, suffering from frostbite and exposure, had to be evacuated. Eventually it was decided that the campaign could not meet its objectives and the British and Dominion forces should withdraw. Many thought a withdrawal would result in heavy casualties. However, elaborate precautions were taken to deceive the Turks into thinking nothing unusual was happening.Between the 18th-20th December 90,000 men were embarked from Suvla and Anzac. On the 8-9th January 1916 a similar evacuation was conducted at Helles. Only a handful of casualties were suffered, no lives were lost.
The British Empire, Dominion and French forces suffered severely in Gelibolu. More than 21,200 British, 10,000 French, 8,700 Australians, 2,700 New Zealanders, 1,350 Indians and 49 Newfoundlanders were killed. The Allied wounded totalled over 97,000.
In Australia and New Zealand people looked in growing disbelief at the mounting casualty lists. Gelibolu was the beginning of a long road for Anzac soldiers that took the survivors to the even more costly battlefields of France and Belgium.
Walking among Gravestones
My physical approach to the sites of all the stories above is from the Turkish side. I am riding south-west down the Peninsular from the direction of the town of Gelibolu.I camp among the olives between the road and the water. I can see along the dog-leg of the Dardenelles and watch the big ships slowly navigate the turns. I am not aware of it at the time, but i am looking at the Narrows, where the naval action took place. Had I been camped here in March 1915 I would have been terrified by the noise, been able to see the smoke and some of the ships, but I would have been safe. The olive trees were already here then and they're doing fine!
I take to the hills. Just a whim. That and the desire to avoid retracing my steps. Where I can, I have always preferred to return by a different route from that by which I arrived. I turn off the main road at Akbaş Şehitliği.
Akbaş Şehitliği is a memorial cemetery with 2000 headstones. There were hospitals based here in 1915. The headstones show mostly 20 somethings, quite a few 30 somethings and a few teenagers. Like elsewhere in WWI not all deaths were on the battlefields, or even directly from wounds in battle. It commemorates those who were treated and didn't make it, and those who died of disease while here. All Ottoman. All dead.
I ride at right angles to the Dardenelles and up onto the hills along the spine of the Peninsular. Through small farming villages, where the streets are narrow. Only walls, no yards, bounding the main road. The red tiled rooves are in various stages of dilapidation: wavy ridges, prolapsed eaves. The soil is a pale brown, not the rich dark chocolate colour of the valleys further north. I do a steep climb to arrive in Büyük Anafarta, which is 4 or 5 kilometres from the 1915 front line.
![]() |
| Riding by red rooves. |
The path I've taken is also one of the supply routes to troops defending the Suvla Bay invasion. The Turks had good supply lines for food and ammunition. Water was easily accessible too because of the existing system of irrigation. All throughout Greece, the Balkans and Turkey, water is gravity fed from mountain streams to water points many kilometres away. These are still functioning and used by locals and cycle tourists today. The Allies, on the other hand, struggled for water. Everything had to be supplied by sea and any wounded had to be taken off-shore.
As I ride into the main square it's easy to see that money has been spent on commemorating the war. There's a new sculpture of Attaturk, Colonel Kemal. He's in army uniform, standing over a lectern, writing and looking into the middle distance. There are new permanent posters, 3m tall and 6m long with photographs and text, showing local buildings and people from 1915. There are half a dozen men noisily finishing off the new paving. The headline, emblazoned over the photo display reads, in Turkish and English, "The victory of Çanakkale is a magnificent saga of Turkish nation who reared up to reclaim its homeland. [sic] "
And that, in a nutshell, is how the Turks see it. Unjustly attacked, all they could do was defend their home. Despite the odds, they beat two of the greatest European powers of the day!
I ride down the hill to the sea, west to Suvla Bay. The road surface becomes steadily worse. After I reach the flat coastal plain it heads south and I head north, and then west. Once I turn west I am on gravel. I pass a couple of farms and it turns to dirt. There are fewer and fewer wheel tracks in the dirt and it becomes sandier and sandier. I can sense the ocean is close but I can't see it. A low headland becomes apparent and I take the fork that leads me up. Finally I find a way through fields of stubble and prickles to the headland. I pitch my tent 3 metres from the edge and 30m above sea level.
I didn't know, the night I camped there, what I know now. At the time I felt exhilarated. The wind is strong but I swim and wash. I can see no one. To the north Suvla Bay sweeps like a scimitar around to the small rocky bays around Büyük Kemikli Yaziti, a memorial to Turkish defenders with its super-sized flag. This is the north headland of Suvla Bay and the northern tip of the Gelibolu Peninsular. To the south the beach runs out of sight toward Anzac Cove. The land is flat, the vegetation low. There are few trees and none over 5m.
Looking west I can see two islands. One Greek, one Turkish. The Greek island has no lights at night. I eat fresh bread with olive oil, salt, fresh goat's cheese and tomatoes. The sun goes down stupendously! I feel clean and renewed and blessed.
The next morning, refreshed, I leave, retracing my tracks through the sand, dirt and gravel.
One kilometre east from my camp is the Lala Baba cemetery. It's about a kilometre south from the Lala Baba hill, which is not that much higher, but commands a great view of Suvla Bay and the salt lake and the hinterland. It's here I first learn of the great stuff-up that was the August 1915 Suvla invasion. The cemetery has 260 names of allied troops, a drop in the bucket of blood.
I ride past low hills that I would not otherwise note, except they are signposted and named: Scimitar Hill, Chocolate Gill, Green Hill, Hill 60. At the time they were significant. Their capture and defence, for either side, marked great achievement at huge cost. All farmland now. It feels isolated and un-peopled. Easy enough country to walk through. Of little value to Britain or France in itself, a means to an end only.
I am stopped by roadworks and the English speaking engineer engages with me. We chat in the shade of a walnut tree for an hour. The government is extending the Anzac infrastructure further north to take in Suvla Bay and Büyük Anafarta. A proper two lane road with shoulders. His team includes two archeologists and he shows me artefacts they have recovered that week: a short length of rusted barbed wire, a cup sized metal lid, a shell casing.
![]() |
| 103 year old barbed wire. |
I ride south again, getting closer to Ariburnu. As I do the coastal plain narrows. The sandy soil gives way to the hard stone-infested soil of the peninsula. The hills, at first gently sloping and some distance from the water, become steeper and closer.
Anzac Cove
Anzac Cove is benign now. Green lawns, wheelchair friendly paved paths, bilingual information plaques with maps and photos. Tourist coaches roll in, roll out. Mostly Turkish people get off the buses the day I'm there. No one stays long, fifteen minutes, if that long.I have time between the bus rushes to read the information plaques. One of them pulls tears from my eyes in a quick rush. It's one sentence.
"On the morning of the 7th August at the Nek, four waves of Australians were cut down before they reached the enemy line."
That's all it takes.
I don't know how many Australians were in one wave.
I don't know how it would feel to stand in wave 2 knowing what was expected of you.
Let alone the grim and harrowing certainty of waves 3 and 4.
The thoughts and feelings of the men waiting to die, knowing certainly and completely their life was over. How would I have stood there? Crying? Praying? Calm? Numb? Regretful? At peace?
The absurdity of persisting in the face of carnage. The reckless stupid loss of life.
Each individual death a pebble in the pond of lovers, parents, siblings, friends and family far away, who weeks later read the fatal news. Ripples of loss and grief.
A bus pulls in and I walk away, back to Pani and a drink of water and a nose blow. An older man asks me if I'm alright. "I'm upset," I say.
"Who upset you?" he asks.
I'm unsure what to say at first, "I suppose, the British!"
He is quiet for a moment, then says, "You must be Australian."
He's a 75 year old Turkish Cypriot who lives in the UK. Jamal. He's friendly. We chat about his life and things. He says goodbye. His bus leaves. I appreciate the contact, the acknowledgement.
The physical geography, from what I can tell in retrospect, is unchanged. The water covers rocks as big as rockmelons. No sandy bottom, but trip hazards at every step. From the beach, which is narrow and pebbly there is a 2m lip to gain solid ground. There is lawn where the memorial is now, but it would have been dense prickle bushes, like it remains on either side. The high ground, beyond the cove, is above perpendicular cliffs, and they are close to the beach, providing easy sight lines as the dawn became day and the light improved.
It's frightening to think of what they had to do when you stand in that space.
![]() |
| The green grass is the Anzac reserve, the peak above was called 'The Sphinx' by the Anzacs. |
![]() |
| It's a green lawn, a path and a stone wall with inform-ation boards. The Sphinx is out of frame to the left |
The south side of Ariburnu, where the Anzacs also came ashore, differs only in that the hills are closer to the shore and the slopes are not as steep.
![]() |
| Looking north from Ariburnu. The break in the vegetation above the beach is the Anzac park. |
Turkish Valour.
From Anzac Cove and south the road is first class. Anzac tourism (and that counts Turks just as much as Aussies and Kiwis) is a money spinner and the infrastructure is good. Three kilometres south of the Cove there is a new bitumen road that turns and runs up along the ridge that the Anzacs so desperately fought to gain. There are half a dozen major memorial and commemorative sites and just as many minor historical sites, signposted and with information boards.There is, along this road, a stronger Turkish presence. Not only is this commemorated on Turkish soil, the Turks were the victors. Despite WWI ending the Ottoman Empire, the Çanakkale campaign (as the Turks call it) had a beginning, an end and a winner. History is written by the victors.
I remember being in a small 600 year old village talking, via device, with the local farmers over çay. One farmer, wrinkled and bent like an olive tree, when told I was from Australia, immediately asked, "Why did you come here and try to kill us?" Confronted, I responded with the analogy of a child following it's parent's example. Australia, as a nation, was only 14 years old, and the Mother country (as Britain was called) had asked for help. He seemed satisfied with that. It wasn't personal to Turkey, we were doing what we were told.
From a few sources I've been told that, in school, Turks are taught that the Anzacs did not know why they were in Turkey. The Anzacs did not have a motive. Unlike the Turks who were fighting for their homes.
There does feel like there is a Turkish goodwill towards Australians. An association with Anzac appears positive. Turks have referred me to the following statement more than once.
"Those heroes that shed their blood and lost their lives... you are now lying in the soil of a friendly country. Therefore rest in peace. There is no difference between the Johnnies and the Mehemets to us where they lie side by side here in this country of ours... You, the mothers, who sent your sons from far away countries wipe away your tears; your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well." Attaturk.1934.☆
Along this road is the statue of the Turkish soldier holding a wounded Allied soldier in his arms, carrying him to safety. The noble Mehemet.
The road passes Lone Pine. Now it is a memorial site for Anzac troops, commemorating by name nearly 5,000 men who have no known grave. On 1915 it was the scene of some of the bloodiest fighting as first one side, and then the other, attempted to drive their enemy out of the trenches and regain ground.
The Anzacs captured the ground were the memorial now stands as part of the 6th August offensive. The Turks lost 7,614 troops counter-attacking over the next three days, but the Anzacs held the ground until the December withdrawal.
Further along the ridge is a memorial for Turkish soldiers. Here, again, I am shocked to the core and tears fall. This is what I read, from the pen of Colonel Kemal:
"The distance between the mutual trenches is eight metres, meaning death is certain, certain..... Those in the first trench fall with no survivors and those in the second trench are moving into place behind them. But do you know they are doing so with decency and trust in God worth envying? They see the dying ones, they know that they too will die in three minutes yet they do not show any bits of concern; no signs of being shocked! Those who know how to read are holding the Quran in their hands and preparing to enter heaven. Those who do not know are reciting the Kalima Shahadat♤. This is an example showing the spiritual power within the Turkish soldiers worth marveling and complimenting. You must know for certain that this spirit is the thing that assured us to win the Battle of Gallipoli."
I'm reminded of Pink Floyd's words, "The generals sat while the lines on the map moved from side to side".
Which perhaps does Kemal a disservice. He was known for being on the frontline with his troops. He once said, ‘I do not order you to attack. I order you to die. In the time which passes until we die other troops and commanders can take our places to fight the invaders’. The soldiers got up from the ground and ran into the machine guns’ fire.
Kemal didn't run toward the machine guns with his troops.
![]() |
| Looking north from Chunuk Bair over hills behind Anzac Cove to Suvla Bay. |
At the highest point of the road, at Chunuk Bair, the 1915 goal of Allied endeavours, is a huge statue of Kemal and a memorial to the New Zealand fallen.
One cannot blame a resident from defending their home when attacked. It is tragic that the warfare of the time treated humans as cannon fodder.
Museum
I have more to learn, however. At the bottom of the hill, away from the Anzac site is a new museum of the Çanakkale campaign. The Kabatepe Promotion Centre and Museum.It has a stunning hour long multimedia presentation that is immersive and visceral. It has the expected displays: uniforms, guns, maps. It also has a background perspective that is new information to me.
![]() |
| The famous two bullets that collided mid-flight. |
From the Turkish perspective the 19th century saw the colonial powers (Portugal, Spain, Netherlands, Britain and France) seeking to preserve their existing colonies, to control and preserve security of the routes to the colonies, to open new fields of capital accumulation and, most importantly, restrict the hegemony of countries such as Germany and Belgium, which had just begun their colonial activities.
As alliance agreements were signed countries with no overseas colonies, like Russia and the Ottoman empire, constituted not only parties in diplomatic relations, but targets within the framework of colonizing European states. They viewed Russia as an important raw material supplier, a granary and human capital reserve. The Ottoman empire was a power that needed to be kept under control in the short term, and a target in the long run due to its control over the Straits, its oil reserves in the Middle East, and the commercial significance of Egypt and the Suez Canal.
![]() |
| Artist's model of trenches. |
When hostilities in Europe first broke out after the assassination in Sarajevo, many nations (who were not caught up in the series of alliances that catapulted the Austria - Serbia conflict into a 'World War') declared their neutrality. The Ottoman did this, but secretly approached England and France for an alliance. England and France had their eyes on the oilfields and territory held by the Ottomans in what is now the Middle East, from modern Turkey to the Red Sea including Israel, Jordan, Palestine, Lebanon, Syria and Iraq. They agreed between themselves on how they would divide it up and refused to make an alliance with the Ottoman.
While still a neutral state the Ottomans purchased two warships from Germany. The Germans insisted that on day 1 the new vessels join German exercises on the Black Sea. While on this exercise the Germans opened fire on Russian ships. So the Ottomans entered the war in a de facto way. On 2nd November 1914 Russia declared war on the Ottoman empire. France and Britain, as per alliance, declared war on the Ottoman on November 6th.
Greed. Imperialist, colonizing avarice, combined with racist arrogance, was a key driver of the Gallipoli campaign.
That's not what they said on the advertisements for recruits. It's not what I was taught in school. (Has that changed?) I've never heard it mentioned at an Anzac Day address. It sure does detract from the "noble sacrifice" view of Anzac fatalities. Dead Australians. Dead Kiwis. Dead Turks. Dead Britons. Dead Canadians.Dead French. Dead Ottomans. Dead Indians.
My convictions and impressions of the Anzacs have not changed since visiting the sites and learning more of both Allied and Turkish experiences. I am now far more convinced that it was a disgusting waste of humanity.
"Unless a nation's life faces peril, war is murder." Attaturk.
It's easier to understand that Turks see this passage of events as glorious than to understand the Anzac glorification.
C.E.W. Bean, the Australian official WWI historian, said, "Anzac stood, and still stands, for reckless valour in a good cause, for enterprise, resourcefulness, fidelity, comradeship, and endurance that will never own defeat."
I call bullshit.
I have little doubt that the individuals were enterprising, resourceful, faithful, good mates and had endurance.
Their courage (valour) I have more respect for now than ever before.
It was not, however, a good cause.
The recklessness belongs to those in charge who threw men's lives away.
"...never own defeat"? Imagine if the officers on the ground had been listened to on that night of 25th April 1915. If there had been a withdrawal. If everyone had gone home. From a tactical point of view of the outcome, nothing would be different. Just an hundred thousand lives saved.
"...never own defeat"? Yeah right! All those Anzacs that desperately wanted to stay on after the withdrawal....I think not!
It's a form of denial. A silk purse out of a sow's ear.
By the time the campaign ended, more than 130,000 men had died: at least 87,000 Ottoman soldiers and 44,000 Allied soldiers, including more than 8700 Australians and 2779 New Zealanders.
It was another time, with values I do not share. My worth is not proved by how I die but how I live.
Bless
Notes
Compulsory military training for the nation's young men was reintroduced in 1951 by the Liberal Government. It was the third such scheme to have existed in Australia since Federation. Eighteen-year-old men were required to partake in the National Service scheme, which meant that they had to undertake 176 days of military training. Those who elected to undertake their training in the army could break up their training requirements into two periods, 98 days in the regular army and 78 days in the Citizen Military Forces (CMF). Those who elected to undertake their training with the RAN or the RAAF had to complete their 176 days in one stretch. The scheme was criticised as being irrelevant to modern defence needs, where skill was becoming more important than numbers, and for being a drain on the regular army's finances and manpower. In 1959 the scheme was abolished.
National service was brought back for a fourth time in 1964, and in May 1965 the Liberal government introduced new powers that enabled it to send national servicemen overseas. At that time Australian soldiers were involved with the war in Vietnam, and the Menzies government wished to raise the army's numbers to 40,000 in order to meet overseas commitments. All 20-year-old males had to register with the Department of Labour and National Service, and their names were selected by the "birthday ballot", in which men were randomly selected for national service by their date of birth. Exemptions were given to Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders, the medically unfit, and theology students. Young men were granted exemption on the grounds of conscientious objection only if they could prove their objection to war was based on religious beliefs. A temporary deferment of national service was granted to university students, apprentices, married men, and those who could prove that national service would cause them financial hardship. Those who were selected for national service were required to serve for two years full-time in the regular army, and three years part-time in the reserves.
The National Service Scheme was abolished on 5 December 1972 by the newly elected Labor government.
Source: https://www.awm.gov.au/articles/encyclopedia/conscription/vietnam
** Ottoman and Turkish are not strictly interchangeable (even though I and many others do that). The Ottoman Empire covered far more than Turkey and its army included troops from all over the empire, including what is now called Iraq, Syria, Armenia, Georgia, Lebanon and Palestine. During the Ottomans time what we think of as Turkey was called Anatolia.
***Mustapha Kemal is lionised in Turkey for far more than the Çanakkale campaign. That was only the start. After WWI and the fall of the Ottoman Empire he led the army in the Turkish War of Independence against Russia, Greece, France and Britain. He was the architect of modern Turkey, it's first president and earned the sobriquet 'father of Turkey', Attaturk, for his vision and nation building.
◇ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/history/world-war-one/inside-first-world-war/part-six/10607886/gallipoli-landing-victoria-crosses.html♧
https://www.awm.gov.au/visit/exhibitions/anzac-voices/landing
♤
(Islam) the formal content of the shahada (declaration of faith): "There is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah."
☆ https://amp.theguardian.com/news/2015/apr/20/ataturks-johnnies-and-mehmets-words-about-the-anzacs-are-shrouded-in-doubt The conclusion of this article is that these words, as written, were never uttered by Attaturk. This appears to be not well known by Turks, who often referenced it to me and appear to identify it as a sign of a special bond with Australians and New Zealanders.





















Comments
Post a Comment